[{"id":"5d4ed4ec-5abe-4404-b517-9790411cfd03","company_lo":"0105d9b2-fc21-460e-83e0-a05e55094bca","company_hi":"d5a791eb-9218-440a-bd0e-94b754f2fe36","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (197601036N vs 202145037C) are conclusive proof of two distinct legal entities. Names also differ ('HAI YANG' vs 'HAI XING'), and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. Both proposer and skeptic agree unanimously on keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"3e68c282007149c191ccffbfe7b43aba83f1b2f8753c4c1250b451a5937982b1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:00.528092+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c75a7e28-8ee8-459a-af84-8b24e28b909c","company_lo":"0105d9b2-fc21-460e-83e0-a05e55094bca","company_hi":"d5a791eb-9218-440a-bd0e-94b754f2fe36","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN:197601036N and Entity B has UEN:202145037C. These are distinct government-issued registration numbers, proving these are two separate legal entities. Furthermore, the names differ — 'HAI YANG' vs 'HAI XING' — and the detector's own fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. There is no shared domain, no shared alias, and no overlapping identifier. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"3e68c282007149c191ccffbfe7b43aba83f1b2f8753c4c1250b451a5937982b1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:00.528092+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"840e7b2c-5385-4ad9-a398-ef8da84b9d25","company_lo":"0105d9b2-fc21-460e-83e0-a05e55094bca","company_hi":"d5a791eb-9218-440a-bd0e-94b754f2fe36","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (197601036N vs 202145037C) are conclusive government-issued registration numbers proving two distinct legal entities. Additionally, the names differ ('YANG' vs 'XING') and the fuzzy match score is only 0.330. No domain or other shared identifiers exist. Under rule: conflicting identifiers demand keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"3e68c282007149c191ccffbfe7b43aba83f1b2f8753c4c1250b451a5937982b1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:00.528092+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"38d51064-4f62-4404-8bb9-115376d475c9","company_lo":"02a47eae-1c2d-40df-964e-f238890b91c4","company_hi":"6a7c145b-996d-4c67-83c6-ae6f5766ccd7","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both records have distinct, conflicting government-issued UENs (29311000W vs 52911174L), which is conclusive proof of separate legal entities. The names differ, the fuzzy score is low (0.330), and there are no shared domains or aliases. Both proposer and skeptic agree unanimously.","evidence_hash":"2fa7cccbd28cc676e64a29c0da8deb652a4e2ead65741400d1e2fd209aaa7635","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:38.746418+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"98ba404a-dda4-48c7-b082-c04e33741af0","company_lo":"02a47eae-1c2d-40df-964e-f238890b91c4","company_hi":"6a7c145b-996d-4c67-83c6-ae6f5766ccd7","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:29311000W for HWA CONSTRUCTION and UEN:52911174L for WAVE CONSTRUCTION. These are distinct government-issued UENs, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The name similarity ('HWA' vs 'WAVE') is superficial and phonetic at best, and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. No shared domains, aliases, or any other merging signals are present. These are unambiguously separate entities.","evidence_hash":"2fa7cccbd28cc676e64a29c0da8deb652a4e2ead65741400d1e2fd209aaa7635","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:38.746418+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"91e89d95-8a3e-48ec-9903-6b414bd691b7","company_lo":"02a47eae-1c2d-40df-964e-f238890b91c4","company_hi":"6a7c145b-996d-4c67-83c6-ae6f5766ccd7","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued registry identifiers (UEN:29311000W vs UEN:52911174L) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Name similarity is irrelevant.","evidence_hash":"2fa7cccbd28cc676e64a29c0da8deb652a4e2ead65741400d1e2fd209aaa7635","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:38.746418+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"473acaf1-10d9-43bb-b7da-22421ce903b1","company_lo":"088cf7dd-98c7-4df2-a635-ac5221902a1f","company_hi":"84875ab7-7cfa-4251-a3ac-ba44939fb0a9","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (201713830K vs 200613052M) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names also differ (QUBER vs QUUE) and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is low. Both proposer and skeptic agree unanimously.","evidence_hash":"b1cb86940f290f8988ba8ad4eec08b177adf9cc800c6210d26b283138e831a0c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:46.77965+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"958af57d-f8f9-48a8-a3a0-6a934fd912e3","company_lo":"088cf7dd-98c7-4df2-a635-ac5221902a1f","company_hi":"84875ab7-7cfa-4251-a3ac-ba44939fb0a9","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 201713830K and Entity B has UEN 200613052M. These are distinct Singapore-registered legal entities. The company names are also different — 'QUBER' vs 'QUUE' — and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is low. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"b1cb86940f290f8988ba8ad4eec08b177adf9cc800c6210d26b283138e831a0c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:46.77965+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"9224b12e-fe1c-435b-80d4-3d8ec13de0ca","company_lo":"088cf7dd-98c7-4df2-a635-ac5221902a1f","company_hi":"84875ab7-7cfa-4251-a3ac-ba44939fb0a9","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting unique entity numbers (UENs) conclusively establish separate legal entities. Entity A UEN:201713830K, Entity B UEN:200613052M. Additionally, the names differ (QUBER vs QUUE), and the detector's fuzzy score is very low (0.330), confirming the mismatch.","evidence_hash":"b1cb86940f290f8988ba8ad4eec08b177adf9cc800c6210d26b283138e831a0c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:46.77965+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"34708e63-424d-462e-9882-e2243db1a8dc","company_lo":"0da10526-d410-421a-bebb-327812d5b3c8","company_hi":"7ba8c2c7-7b68-4f65-81d6-8a629a2e9b43","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (200804172W vs 199001934M) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names differ substantially, and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"ecd7b5a66e984cd5faae6174bd2d6bfa89f9f6aef6432b4e0b86b95be8d1fd4a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:38.004851+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"9689eab1-489f-454d-a54e-b03018b6c5be","company_lo":"0da10526-d410-421a-bebb-327812d5b3c8","company_hi":"7ba8c2c7-7b68-4f65-81d6-8a629a2e9b43","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: 200804172W for CESA INVESTMENTS PTE. LTD. and 199001934M for EPS INVESTMENTS PTE LTD. These are government-issued registry identifiers and their conflict is conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names differ substantially (CESA vs EPS), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"ecd7b5a66e984cd5faae6174bd2d6bfa89f9f6aef6432b4e0b86b95be8d1fd4a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:38.004851+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"328578b9-872e-44f8-96b5-46f99e0a1a61","company_lo":"0da10526-d410-421a-bebb-327812d5b3c8","company_hi":"7ba8c2c7-7b68-4f65-81d6-8a629a2e9b43","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (200804172W vs 199001934M) provide conclusive evidence these are distinct legal entities. Registry identifiers take precedence over any superficial name or domain overlap, and the names CESA INVESTMENTS PTE. LTD. and EPS INVESTMENTS PTE LTD are clearly different. The low detector score (0.330) further supports different entities.","evidence_hash":"ecd7b5a66e984cd5faae6174bd2d6bfa89f9f6aef6432b4e0b86b95be8d1fd4a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:38.004851+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5b68e88f-a437-4e76-81f5-939b08b87a1c","company_lo":"0df9b7ca-9020-4e70-b6fd-db4e3f61e608","company_hi":"345564f6-5f78-488e-b366-b0a7039ded47","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (29737600D vs 38052200D) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names also differ substantially ('PIT TAT' vs 'TAT LIP'), and the detector fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. The proposer's case is correct and compelling; the skeptic produced no meaningful objection. These are unambiguously different entities.","evidence_hash":"5b3b2b94a04423c4545dcb38abb4c750249b793249a625fceb80f29b822cf4a4","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:56:39.592872+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"9507f3a3-c85e-485c-9658-b64cf82e9bbd","company_lo":"0df9b7ca-9020-4e70-b6fd-db4e3f61e608","company_hi":"345564f6-5f78-488e-b366-b0a7039ded47","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers (UEN:29737600D vs UEN:38052200D) are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ substantially ('PIT TAT' vs 'TAT LIP'), and the detector score of 0.330 is very low. No shared domains, aliases, or any other merging signals exist. These are unambiguously distinct entities.","evidence_hash":"5b3b2b94a04423c4545dcb38abb4c750249b793249a625fceb80f29b822cf4a4","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:56:39.592872+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c75676f0-63c3-44cc-8c2d-9a604c81c63b","company_lo":"0df9b7ca-9020-4e70-b6fd-db4e3f61e608","company_hi":"345564f6-5f78-488e-b366-b0a7039ded47","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"5b3b2b94a04423c4545dcb38abb4c750249b793249a625fceb80f29b822cf4a4","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:56:39.592872+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"85865904-3482-4cc4-9892-8811943665e7","company_lo":"0e4f6f0a-155e-41a0-a586-40a6bf32ae82","company_hi":"5cf6efe7-8bde-46aa-a09e-3b9795fb9841","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.720,"rationale":"Entity A ('Flipkart Internet Pvt Ltd') and Entity B ('Flipkart Internet') share the distinctive proper noun 'Flipkart Internet' — Flipkart is not a generic term but a well-known brand. Entity A simply appends the Indian legal suffix 'Pvt Ltd', a classic pattern of full legal name vs. short/trade name for the same entity. No conflicting registry identifiers, domains, or country signals are present. The skeptic failed to produce a substantive counterargument. The proposer's reasoning is sound: the distinctive brand name match, absence of any disqualifying signals, and known real-world entity make this a merge. Confidence is moderate-high rather than full due to the absence of corroborating identifiers or domain data.","evidence_hash":"1223bf23e43384f6bf1e7cfa1a30a50e0dfe60514e250c4b36800b0665e615c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:59.311954+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cfd8e8c7-ea72-4ae5-909e-510e373708a9","company_lo":"0e4f6f0a-155e-41a0-a586-40a6bf32ae82","company_hi":"5cf6efe7-8bde-46aa-a09e-3b9795fb9841","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.620,"rationale":"Entity A ('Flipkart Internet Pvt Ltd') and Entity B ('Flipkart Internet') share the same core name 'Flipkart Internet', with Entity A simply including the legal suffix 'Pvt Ltd' (Private Limited) indicating its Indian corporate registration form. This is a classic pattern where one record contains the full legal name and the other contains the common trade/short name of the same entity. No conflicting registry identifiers are present (no identifiers provided at all), no conflicting domains, and no conflicting country information. The well-known Flipkart brand is a single Indian e-commerce entity, and 'Flipkart Internet Pvt Ltd' is its registered legal name. The absence of any disqualifying signals combined with the meaningful name overlap (not just common words — 'Flipkart' is a distinctive proper noun) supports a merge verdict. Confidence is moderate rather than high due to the lack of corroborating identifiers or domain evidence.","evidence_hash":"1223bf23e43384f6bf1e7cfa1a30a50e0dfe60514e250c4b36800b0665e615c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:59.311954+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"fbd79c31-e6aa-4176-a043-e5b84e8e0d2e","company_lo":"0e4f6f0a-155e-41a0-a586-40a6bf32ae82","company_hi":"5cf6efe7-8bde-46aa-a09e-3b9795fb9841","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"1223bf23e43384f6bf1e7cfa1a30a50e0dfe60514e250c4b36800b0665e615c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:59.311954+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"db6a7949-8246-42b0-ab23-067da3b8e1d2","company_lo":"15a92923-c4ad-4f18-a715-c53bc82aa5d4","company_hi":"a7e7f842-fbaf-4b33-9a9a-c3172512fbf0","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (52988407X vs 52888176X) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Names differ in meaningful prefixes (KH vs PCK), and the low fuzzy score (0.330) reflects only generic word overlap in 'CONTRACT & DESIGN'. No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"a3c8dfa8c2608029d3bd7fbba475fc2cdf80c5b09a3439695b57d1ce46db0e33","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.451022+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e8b6e9f4-00ec-43c9-bcce-d6556ddfc03c","company_lo":"15a92923-c4ad-4f18-a715-c53bc82aa5d4","company_hi":"a7e7f842-fbaf-4b33-9a9a-c3172512fbf0","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (52988407X vs 52888176X), which are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names are clearly different — 'KH CONTRACT & DESIGN' vs 'PCK CONTRACT & DESIGN' — with different prefixes (KH vs PCK). The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low, consistent with only superficial similarity in the generic words 'CONTRACT & DESIGN'. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"a3c8dfa8c2608029d3bd7fbba475fc2cdf80c5b09a3439695b57d1ce46db0e33","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.451022+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"af44c613-1717-4151-8c1c-2d9c82d27d7c","company_lo":"15a92923-c4ad-4f18-a715-c53bc82aa5d4","company_hi":"a7e7f842-fbaf-4b33-9a9a-c3172512fbf0","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Different UENs (52988407X vs 52888176X) are conclusive proof of separate legal entities. Names differ in the prefixes (KH vs PCK) and the business suffixes are generic. The low detector score (0.330) reflects only superficial word overlap. No shared domain, address, or other linking evidence exists.","evidence_hash":"a3c8dfa8c2608029d3bd7fbba475fc2cdf80c5b09a3439695b57d1ce46db0e33","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.451022+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4159faef-7cbf-42cd-8f01-7f0bfa0b64cf","company_lo":"17f1f121-55ed-494b-b0b9-006d8c1b4e6e","company_hi":"b8d24491-0cf3-4227-83cf-bab9b77d8c39","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (200308683C vs 198300396M) conclusively establish these are distinct legal entities. Names also differ (SPI vs API). No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"689a951165ee81cc02fda1b93cad47799448a2a854f739e4015fb60c293edcf3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:51.036898+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b3e1460f-69f8-4e30-9493-a7948c81195c","company_lo":"17f1f121-55ed-494b-b0b9-006d8c1b4e6e","company_hi":"b8d24491-0cf3-4227-83cf-bab9b77d8c39","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: UEN:200308683C for SPI TECHNOLOGY PTE. LTD. and UEN:198300396M for API TECHNOLOGY PTE. LTD. These are government-issued registry identifiers and their conflict is conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Furthermore, the names differ (SPI vs API prefix), and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is low. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"689a951165ee81cc02fda1b93cad47799448a2a854f739e4015fb60c293edcf3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:51.036898+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"8758db6b-b485-4c78-ae1c-d59da09dd66f","company_lo":"17f1f121-55ed-494b-b0b9-006d8c1b4e6e","company_hi":"b8d24491-0cf3-4227-83cf-bab9b77d8c39","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs: UEN:200308683C vs UEN:198300396M. Different government-issued identifiers provide conclusive proof of distinct legal entities, regardless of any surface name similarity (SPI vs API) or detector score.","evidence_hash":"689a951165ee81cc02fda1b93cad47799448a2a854f739e4015fb60c293edcf3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:51.036898+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"7105ee3f-ee74-413a-a17e-0db945c05b8b","company_lo":"185e2377-8d28-4c0c-9b0b-818b2d2e333a","company_hi":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct Singapore UENs (201710305E vs 199301693E), which constitutes conclusive proof of different legal entities under council rules. The low fuzzy score (0.330), distinct names, and absence of any shared domains or aliases further confirm separation. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"10e074606834b4e0e57a1658dc6a1bdb23576afe331f25e71fc4003d43a15f8c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:23.121624+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"601dc699-9b84-4d23-b193-fac8a030ad8f","company_lo":"185e2377-8d28-4c0c-9b0b-818b2d2e333a","company_hi":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: Entity A has UEN:201710305E and Entity B has UEN:199301693E. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued registry identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names are distinct ('EDEN ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION PTE. LTD.' vs 'D N ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION PTE LTD'), the fuzzy detector score is low at 0.330, and there are no shared domains or aliases. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"10e074606834b4e0e57a1658dc6a1bdb23576afe331f25e71fc4003d43a15f8c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:23.121624+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"3866c9f3-6334-445f-82f7-14961192cb41","company_lo":"185e2377-8d28-4c0c-9b0b-818b2d2e333a","company_hi":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (201710305E vs 199301693E) are conclusive government-issued identifiers proving different legal entities. The rule states 'Conflicting registry identifiers ... are CONCLUSIVE proof they are different entities — vote keep_apart regardless of name similarity, shared domains, or detector score.' The name overlap ('ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION PTE. LTD.') is generic and does not override the identifier conflict. Thus, they are distinct.","evidence_hash":"10e074606834b4e0e57a1658dc6a1bdb23576afe331f25e71fc4003d43a15f8c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:23.121624+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"db8cdfc2-011d-4535-98c7-ae2259594d0e","company_lo":"19b0a7c4-2d53-4600-a474-faae1aaf660b","company_hi":"35efb151-5089-4163-9b19-0b94f46c03a9","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the conflicting UENs (202015540M vs 200413739W) are conclusive proof these are distinct legal entities. The names also differ materially ('NOMAD' vs 'MADA'), the fuzzy score is low (0.330), and no shared domains or aliases exist. Keep apart.","evidence_hash":"d2ebd740db562f198aa065f44de057d901cba8ce536837748d0d770d3c36e6d3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:57.742437+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c810d75c-7f3b-42db-96bf-028348615f24","company_lo":"19b0a7c4-2d53-4600-a474-faae1aaf660b","company_hi":"35efb151-5089-4163-9b19-0b94f46c03a9","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: Entity A has UEN:202015540M and Entity B has UEN:200413739W. These are government-issued registry identifiers and their conflict is conclusive proof that these are two distinct legal entities. Beyond that, the names differ substantially ('NOMAD' vs 'MADA'), the detector fuzzy score is very low at 0.330, and there are no shared domains or aliases. There is no credible evidence for merging.","evidence_hash":"d2ebd740db562f198aa065f44de057d901cba8ce536837748d0d770d3c36e6d3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:57.742437+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"f0d2d8e6-cfa0-449f-8ca8-abe44ed63c0f","company_lo":"19b0a7c4-2d53-4600-a474-faae1aaf660b","company_hi":"35efb151-5089-4163-9b19-0b94f46c03a9","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Different UENs: Entity A has UEN 202015540M, Entity B has UEN 200413739W. These are unique, government-issued identifiers for Singapore-registered entities. Conflicting UENs are conclusive proof of separate legal entities, regardless of any superficial name similarity or the detector's low-confidence fuzzy score (0.330). The names differ materially ('NOMAD' vs 'MADA'), and no shared domains or aliases exist. They must be different entities.","evidence_hash":"d2ebd740db562f198aa065f44de057d901cba8ce536837748d0d770d3c36e6d3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:57.742437+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"98bc2e85-d3be-485b-ae58-732ea0e9bab5","company_lo":"1c9ef0de-7446-41e7-bcda-ee779de8c9de","company_hi":"a7944053-d8c7-4c8e-a232-4a0d1f72d3cb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (53189013M vs 52845072K) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names are also clearly different, and the detector score of 0.330 is low. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"135616f1680ce37fdeef4bf1b6b1d8e79ae1c7c914affebd6e049ad02c2d7bcb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:22.267471+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"890b5b89-0b73-4070-9bc9-45ec5b053e1e","company_lo":"1c9ef0de-7446-41e7-bcda-ee779de8c9de","company_hi":"a7944053-d8c7-4c8e-a232-4a0d1f72d3cb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: UEN:53189013M (Entity A) vs UEN:52845072K (Entity B) are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving these are different legal entities. The names 'RA ENTERPRISES' and 'ROMAC ENTERPRISES' are also clearly different beyond the generic word 'ENTERPRISES'. The detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports separation. No merging evidence exists.","evidence_hash":"135616f1680ce37fdeef4bf1b6b1d8e79ae1c7c914affebd6e049ad02c2d7bcb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:22.267471+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"6fd55c59-4443-428d-8a95-7f88dff310d1","company_lo":"1c9ef0de-7446-41e7-bcda-ee779de8c9de","company_hi":"a7944053-d8c7-4c8e-a232-4a0d1f72d3cb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two entities have distinct government-issued UEN identifiers (53189013M vs 52845072K). Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive proof of separate legal entities, overriding any surface-level name or domain similarities. The names 'RA ENTERPRISES' and 'ROMAC ENTERPRISES' are also clearly different beyond the generic word 'ENTERPRISES'.","evidence_hash":"135616f1680ce37fdeef4bf1b6b1d8e79ae1c7c914affebd6e049ad02c2d7bcb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:22.267471+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c24716fc-a0ce-4966-9a5f-bba9ccc62afc","company_lo":"1dc7ec8b-21a5-42d1-96fb-205ff9fe3134","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records have conflicting UENs (201934803E vs 52910439C), which are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names also differ materially, and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"967bd4a06b397b1dca0f67bc9e9675de2a5a331a77c86047d367333d926a3647","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:23.867474+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"3b9f594a-1570-4217-9f8e-0f74abb07ccf","company_lo":"1dc7ec8b-21a5-42d1-96fb-205ff9fe3134","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:201934803E for TDCA INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD. and UEN:52910439C for TTD INTERNATIONAL. Conflicting government-issued UENs are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ significantly (TDCA vs TTD, different structures), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"967bd4a06b397b1dca0f67bc9e9675de2a5a331a77c86047d367333d926a3647","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:23.867474+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0b22a0ab-b38a-406a-b8b7-b5562c0b7e79","company_lo":"1dc7ec8b-21a5-42d1-96fb-205ff9fe3134","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (201934803E vs 52910439C) are conclusive evidence of different legal entities. Name similarity and low detector score are irrelevant.","evidence_hash":"967bd4a06b397b1dca0f67bc9e9675de2a5a331a77c86047d367333d926a3647","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:23.867474+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"246a0a71-62a9-4d22-817e-13f93a59cadc","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct UENs (53208615E vs. 201017827N), which is conclusive proof of separate legal entities. Name similarity is superficial (only the generic word 'SOLUTIONS' overlaps), the detector score is very low (0.330), and no other shared signals exist. Keep apart.","evidence_hash":"427a3eb0c75ec3d17c4bb72273a01392cd065f53f5ac20b4e3699c284d862cba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:51.02517+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"20da3530-40a8-4d74-8603-e0992d283c13","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:53208615E for BG SOLUTIONS and UEN:201017827N for GH - SOLUTIONS PTE. LTD. These are distinct government-issued UENs, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The name similarity is superficial (both contain 'SOLUTIONS') and the detector's own fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No shared domains, aliases, or other overlapping signals are present. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"427a3eb0c75ec3d17c4bb72273a01392cd065f53f5ac20b4e3699c284d862cba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:51.02517+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5f4bfd62-93ee-41bd-b54e-ab707b089c50","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers (UEN:53208615E vs. UEN:201017827N) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names share only the generic word 'SOLUTIONS', and the detector's low fuzzy score (0.330) reflects a weak match. No shared domains, aliases, or other entity-linking evidence exists to overcome the definitive identifier mismatch.","evidence_hash":"427a3eb0c75ec3d17c4bb72273a01392cd065f53f5ac20b4e3699c284d862cba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:51.02517+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"adda42cb-d618-4035-9ec6-5ca9726f6e07","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers (UEN:53208615E vs UEN:201510242C), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The names also differ ('BG' vs 'BH'), the fuzzy detector score is very low at 0.330, and there is no shared domain or other overlapping evidence. The proposer's case is clear and the skeptic produced no substantive counter-argument.","evidence_hash":"e196de004b341524800ca1502920aea8bb21ec73d852ca15087ed2ca58f1b4c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:24.939203+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"94a57eb6-acb1-4f7a-86c2-e4bb3c4c41da","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: UEN:53208615E for BG SOLUTIONS and UEN:201510242C for BH SOLUTIONS PTE. LTD. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ ('BG' vs 'BH'), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no shared domain, no shared alias, and no overlapping evidence to support a merge.","evidence_hash":"e196de004b341524800ca1502920aea8bb21ec73d852ca15087ed2ca58f1b4c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:24.939203+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5beefd92-66b6-4de8-a0d6-adcd13d36622","company_lo":"20bc0fed-b548-4ed6-99a0-0885011a43a7","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"e196de004b341524800ca1502920aea8bb21ec73d852ca15087ed2ca58f1b4c6","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:24.939203+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"08338054-1115-4641-8766-57bcb9b32c90","company_lo":"212a4ba5-1bb1-43a3-bd24-6d1b16d15825","company_hi":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (52821490W vs 53115419W) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Both proposer and skeptic agree unanimously. Names also differ (SMM vs SP prefix). No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"c6c2b5abfb133d3b13bcae7f1245f833d8e25ad130ed2d2092ebfd74937f4e65","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:29.654655+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"fc19e49d-5b87-49ab-8df5-e350ba7f6bff","company_lo":"212a4ba5-1bb1-43a3-bd24-6d1b16d15825","company_hi":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: UEN:52821490W vs UEN:53115419W are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving these are different legal entities. The names also differ (SMM vs SP prefix), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"c6c2b5abfb133d3b13bcae7f1245f833d8e25ad130ed2d2092ebfd74937f4e65","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:29.654655+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5f4c0e79-30ba-4dcc-b3d4-471fa2535b65","company_lo":"212a4ba5-1bb1-43a3-bd24-6d1b16d15825","company_hi":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: UEN:52821490W and UEN:53115419W are different government-issued identifiers, proving these are distinct legal entities. The name similarity is irrelevant.","evidence_hash":"c6c2b5abfb133d3b13bcae7f1245f833d8e25ad130ed2d2092ebfd74937f4e65","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:29.654655+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"fe266b39-cd5b-43fd-b9c0-7b884c6ed559","company_lo":"226eca07-73d9-4e3d-8793-bc86d22b95b2","company_hi":"6627ecd5-13e3-4f0a-8492-19a5aad39aa6","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic are in full agreement. Entity A (UEN:202606644K) and Entity B (UEN:202626578N) have distinct government-issued registry identifiers, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The name similarity between 'NEXORA' and 'NEXCOR' is superficial and cannot overcome conflicting UENs. The low detector fuzzy score of 0.330 further corroborates separation.","evidence_hash":"343ef00592eb1139c9dc16d282e301208a757c3823363d3fde5bbb37a7873bc5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-19T06:30:00.216233+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"ff3af189-37fd-425a-bf42-1466c4d89644","company_lo":"226eca07-73d9-4e3d-8793-bc86d22b95b2","company_hi":"6627ecd5-13e3-4f0a-8492-19a5aad39aa6","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 202606644K and Entity B has UEN 202626578N — two distinct government-issued registration numbers. These are different legal entities. The name similarity ('NEXORA' vs 'NEXCOR') is superficial and insufficient to overcome conflicting UENs. The detector's own low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports keeping them apart.","evidence_hash":"343ef00592eb1139c9dc16d282e301208a757c3823363d3fde5bbb37a7873bc5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-19T06:30:00.216233+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"ca3fe146-065b-4e2a-ba69-ea94c99b52af","company_lo":"226eca07-73d9-4e3d-8793-bc86d22b95b2","company_hi":"6627ecd5-13e3-4f0a-8492-19a5aad39aa6","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers: Entity A has UEN 202606644K, Entity B has UEN 202626578N. Different government-issued IDs are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities, regardless of other similarities. The name similarity (NEXORA vs NEXCOR) is superficial, and the low detector score (0.330) further supports separation.","evidence_hash":"343ef00592eb1139c9dc16d282e301208a757c3823363d3fde5bbb37a7873bc5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-19T06:30:00.216233+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"399ff397-5886-4be0-9d72-e675952f1f7b","company_lo":"2618b2d1-f521-4494-99e4-96298297d6a4","company_hi":"4d76380b-593a-4c2e-bb7c-7601ab55a1ea","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct Singapore UENs (201411669N vs 200501619K), which is conclusive proof of separate legal entities. The low fuzzy score (0.33) and differently arranged names further confirm no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"2c61d13aa65798ee3dbccc3b7d6334a2cebc2503a68315b662aa1f94038925b9","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:35.369158+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b12951f9-88a4-4fb5-8f84-ad8ebebeeea1","company_lo":"2618b2d1-f521-4494-99e4-96298297d6a4","company_hi":"4d76380b-593a-4c2e-bb7c-7601ab55a1ea","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: Entity A has UEN 201411669N and Entity B has UEN 200501619K. These are distinct Singapore government-issued registration numbers, which is conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Furthermore, the names, while sharing the words 'STAR' and 'TRAVEL', are arranged differently ('KSTAR TRAVEL' vs 'TRAVEL STAR') and the fuzzy match score of 0.330 is very low. There is no shared domain, no shared aliases, and no overlapping identifiers. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"2c61d13aa65798ee3dbccc3b7d6334a2cebc2503a68315b662aa1f94038925b9","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:35.369158+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"29e9daef-9366-491a-b41a-0465f4d8370f","company_lo":"2618b2d1-f521-4494-99e4-96298297d6a4","company_hi":"4d76380b-593a-4c2e-bb7c-7601ab55a1ea","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (201411669N vs 200501619K) are definitive proof of different legal entities in Singapore. Name similarity (fuzzy score 0.33) and arrangement difference do not outweigh the unique identifiers.","evidence_hash":"2c61d13aa65798ee3dbccc3b7d6334a2cebc2503a68315b662aa1f94038925b9","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:45:35.369158+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"6bddb6cb-8e62-428b-92c1-af4f4b981faf","company_lo":"26ed9045-4ef3-4252-aac4-84e1ab30bc9f","company_hi":"650df781-7954-4151-bcd9-137c9da47e68","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (200608579K vs 200511451D) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Both proposer and skeptic agree. The geographic qualifiers (NZ) vs (NSW) further confirm separate regional incorporations. No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"c0188901742889febdbb235c13ce73d4c4a382f06718cf7ccfa20f99584a0ec5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:34.569124+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0b9bf306-cd5a-4ba8-a2f1-cde07dcbdc86","company_lo":"26ed9045-4ef3-4252-aac4-84e1ab30bc9f","company_hi":"650df781-7954-4151-bcd9-137c9da47e68","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 200608579K while Entity B has UEN 200511451D. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ in their geographic qualifiers — '(NZ)' vs '(NSW)' — suggesting they were incorporated as separate regional entities under the Lasseters brand. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low, and even the name similarity argument is weakened by the differing jurisdiction abbreviations. Identifiers alone mandate keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"c0188901742889febdbb235c13ce73d4c4a382f06718cf7ccfa20f99584a0ec5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:34.569124+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"3293235d-9170-40b5-829d-d16464eeb86a","company_lo":"26ed9045-4ef3-4252-aac4-84e1ab30bc9f","company_hi":"650df781-7954-4151-bcd9-137c9da47e68","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Distinct UENs (200608579K vs 200511451D) conclusively prove these are separate legal entities, regardless of name similarity. The geographic qualifiers '(NZ)' vs '(NSW)' further suggest regional differentiation. Detector score is low.","evidence_hash":"c0188901742889febdbb235c13ce73d4c4a382f06718cf7ccfa20f99584a0ec5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:34.569124+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c18acbc8-1ab1-4463-beb3-08de1eb84a4a","company_lo":"280d2359-03ba-43b1-8c5a-365885851f34","company_hi":"707e552e-ff34-415d-b9c0-77f33e29af22","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (202125443M vs 199202761M) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names differ, fuzzy score is low (0.330). No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"e1af30f400ac8079d04c82427aa22c84b3ca0e3685583f210eceb42ad8d6e0e2","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:55.195763+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c795a0a5-6c00-46d8-9224-18629f4c2912","company_lo":"280d2359-03ba-43b1-8c5a-365885851f34","company_hi":"707e552e-ff34-415d-b9c0-77f33e29af22","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: Entity A has UEN 202125443M and Entity B has UEN 199202761M. These are distinct government-issued registry numbers, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The names are also clearly different ('ZSS MARINE PTE. LTD.' vs 'S & S MARINE PTE LTD'), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"e1af30f400ac8079d04c82427aa22c84b3ca0e3685583f210eceb42ad8d6e0e2","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:55.195763+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"1da2a364-d980-44de-9d9c-f99155b2017e","company_lo":"280d2359-03ba-43b1-8c5a-365885851f34","company_hi":"707e552e-ff34-415d-b9c0-77f33e29af22","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two records have distinct, conflicting government-issued UENs (202125443M vs 199202761M). This is conclusive proof they are different legal entities, per the resolution rules. The low fuzzy match score (0.330) and name differences (ZSS vs S & S) further support separation, but the identifiers alone are decisive.","evidence_hash":"e1af30f400ac8079d04c82427aa22c84b3ca0e3685583f210eceb42ad8d6e0e2","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:55.195763+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"39d395a3-7ccb-4557-9d40-ba6d87e0d6c7","company_lo":"2d6fdf41-79b5-4ea2-b4f4-a6be3a34ee80","company_hi":"8ab41e77-03bf-4251-8d9c-26ca12eebd92","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (53264422X vs 52091300X) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names also differ substantially and the detector score is low. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"bd3dc9330833ca58dd55f36766eef5d0cf68c18bfee6b94fe6107ffb0b8efddf","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:34.649854+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b5d02379-98f5-41bc-a7bf-28a43edaa369","company_lo":"2d6fdf41-79b5-4ea2-b4f4-a6be3a34ee80","company_hi":"8ab41e77-03bf-4251-8d9c-26ca12eebd92","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 53264422X and Entity B has UEN 52091300X. These are distinct government-issued identifiers proving these are different legal entities. The names also differ substantially ('VETRI CLEANING SERVICES' vs 'VRS CLEANING SERVICES'), and the detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports separation. No merging evidence can overcome the conflicting UENs.","evidence_hash":"bd3dc9330833ca58dd55f36766eef5d0cf68c18bfee6b94fe6107ffb0b8efddf","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:34.649854+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c986b9f4-38c1-424a-babd-b1850c0fdd13","company_lo":"2d6fdf41-79b5-4ea2-b4f4-a6be3a34ee80","company_hi":"8ab41e77-03bf-4251-8d9c-26ca12eebd92","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting unique entity numbers (UENs) are conclusive evidence of separate legal entities: A has 53264422X, B has 52091300X. No other evidence can override this. The names also differ ('VETRI' vs 'VRS') and the fuzzy detector score is low (0.330).","evidence_hash":"bd3dc9330833ca58dd55f36766eef5d0cf68c18bfee6b94fe6107ffb0b8efddf","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:34.649854+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"899fd277-6a5d-45bf-b92e-71d264f774c2","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.720,"rationale":"The two records 'BYJU'S' and 'byju's' are identical after case normalization. BYJU'S is a highly distinctive, well-known brand name (the Indian edtech unicorn), making it extremely unlikely that two different entities share this exact unusual name. There are no conflicting registry identifiers, domains, or other disqualifying signals. The skeptic produced no counter-argument. The proposer's case is uncontested and sound. Confidence is moderated by the absence of corroborating identifiers or domain evidence, but the distinctive name match is sufficient for a merge verdict.","evidence_hash":"28dacad3162224120b8c9be29dc5a918249d622099658bf54bf48465270b5461","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:20.841287+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"3a82998f-3224-4371-becd-f75114ef7ec2","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.550,"rationale":"The two records 'BYJU'S' and 'byju's' are identical when normalized to lowercase — they differ only in letter case, which is a trivial typographic variation, not a substantive difference. The detector flagged this via normalized_name matching. 'BYJU'S' is a well-known, highly distinctive brand name (the Indian edtech company), making it extremely unlikely that two different entities would share this exact, unusual name. No conflicting registry identifiers, domains, or other disqualifying signals are present. On the strength of the distinctive name match alone, merging is the most defensible verdict, though confidence is tempered by the lack of corroborating identifiers or domain evidence.","evidence_hash":"28dacad3162224120b8c9be29dc5a918249d622099658bf54bf48465270b5461","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:20.841287+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5e279bbc-56fb-425e-8d53-463563d087e1","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"28dacad3162224120b8c9be29dc5a918249d622099658bf54bf48465270b5461","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:20.841287+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"7733398c-433b-492e-9a20-24e3d7eaa832","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.720,"rationale":"BYJU'S and Byjus are clearly the same distinctive proper noun — the Indian edtech company — differing only in apostrophe and capitalization. The low fuzzy score (0.330) is a string-matching artifact caused by the apostrophe, not evidence of different entities. No registry identifiers, conflicting domains, or aliases are present to contradict a merge. The brand name is unique enough that this is not a generic word collision. The proposer's case is sound; the skeptic failed to produce a substantive objection. Moderate-high confidence given the absence of corroborating identifiers, but the uniqueness of the name is sufficient to support merging.","evidence_hash":"f936d683e12826c8dbb5cfce1e8dd9225c179017e9db7ed2e476e07c858b0b16","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:02.498484+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4fa6f8b9-21be-47c3-986d-390b985c1673","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.550,"rationale":"Both records refer to 'BYJU'S' and 'Byjus' — these are clearly the same brand name, differing only in apostrophe and capitalization. BYJU'S is the well-known Indian edtech company, and 'Byjus' is a common informal rendering of the same name. No registry identifiers are present on either record to contradict this, no conflicting domains or aliases are provided, and the name similarity is not based on generic common words but on a distinctive proper noun. The detector score of 0.330 is low due to fuzzy string matching penalizing the apostrophe, but human judgment recognizes these as the same entity. The absence of any conflicting evidence, combined with the uniqueness of the brand name, supports merging, though moderate confidence is warranted given the thin evidence set (no shared domain, registry ID, or aliases to corroborate).","evidence_hash":"f936d683e12826c8dbb5cfce1e8dd9225c179017e9db7ed2e476e07c858b0b16","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:02.498484+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"059c9a8a-05b7-4f9f-a0ed-ba4059c11da9","company_lo":"3339f2e4-27d1-4704-99b5-f5cbb980ca04","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"f936d683e12826c8dbb5cfce1e8dd9225c179017e9db7ed2e476e07c858b0b16","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:02.498484+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a075b6b2-7cf3-4778-b8cd-926b6106e832","company_lo":"3519686a-80a9-486d-9e9a-292ff2fe0169","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (52917075B vs 52910439C) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Names also differ substantially, and the detector score of 0.330 is low. No basis for a merge.","evidence_hash":"54d68f2a0b364841c1a81b7ef7601e9ed5fadeeb8fe69aa477518db87a01c1b3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:35.221961+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"65dae888-bc82-4413-bca3-b8fc795f107e","company_lo":"3519686a-80a9-486d-9e9a-292ff2fe0169","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:52917075B for JD INTERNATIONAL and UEN:52910439C for TTD INTERNATIONAL. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ substantially ('JD' vs 'TTD'), and the detector's own fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"54d68f2a0b364841c1a81b7ef7601e9ed5fadeeb8fe69aa477518db87a01c1b3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:35.221961+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"614ef3d7-58ce-45f1-816e-1a6e8010fa5f","company_lo":"3519686a-80a9-486d-9e9a-292ff2fe0169","company_hi":"8c118273-ca6a-4b61-8af4-aaf865b2e378","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers (UEN:52917075B vs UEN:52910439C) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names also differ substantially ('JD' vs 'TTD'), and the fuzzy score is low.","evidence_hash":"54d68f2a0b364841c1a81b7ef7601e9ed5fadeeb8fe69aa477518db87a01c1b3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:35.221961+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2b46f4b2-770f-4a01-83a8-6b53e89a2a4e","company_lo":"355867f5-18ca-4168-94d1-b8096a7cb409","company_hi":"ec1ccb92-caaf-4b11-ab3b-c823062310da","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic correctly identify that the two records carry conflicting UENs (202108701R vs 53416012C). Per council rules, conflicting government-issued registry identifiers are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Name similarity between 'HUSTLE HUT PTE. LTD.' and 'HUSTLE HUT' is irrelevant — identifiers win. Additionally, the UEN formats suggest different entity types and registration periods, further corroborating they are separate legal entities.","evidence_hash":"51099d2f04969af2dbdd34c2142717d9052ac76d860fee3979eb873b288a2cb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:44.547228+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"92a845db-1441-4b58-90e9-aaa827df8c94","company_lo":"355867f5-18ca-4168-94d1-b8096a7cb409","company_hi":"ec1ccb92-caaf-4b11-ab3b-c823062310da","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Despite the near-identical names 'HUSTLE HUT PTE. LTD.' and 'HUSTLE HUT', the two records carry conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:202108701R for Entity A and UEN:53416012C for Entity B. Under council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. No shared domain, alias, or name similarity can override this. The records must be kept apart.","evidence_hash":"51099d2f04969af2dbdd34c2142717d9052ac76d860fee3979eb873b288a2cb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:44.547228+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"f502acb9-fe6d-46ca-a63c-d6266a782ffd","company_lo":"355867f5-18ca-4168-94d1-b8096a7cb409","company_hi":"ec1ccb92-caaf-4b11-ab3b-c823062310da","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued identifiers (UEN 202108701R vs UEN 53416012C) are conclusive proof of separate legal entities. Additionally, the UEN formats indicate distinct business structures: 202108701R corresponds to a private limited company (2019–2022 issue year), while 53416012C denotes a sole proprietorship or partnership (issued pre-2009 or in a different range). No name similarity or other evidence can override these immutable contradictions.","evidence_hash":"51099d2f04969af2dbdd34c2142717d9052ac76d860fee3979eb873b288a2cb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:44.547228+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"d8a0464a-0616-4ab5-adb0-08c98ade9241","company_lo":"3e751919-4fff-42be-97c9-e95802707f8b","company_hi":"a9c7f037-ba5c-4622-aa12-e82e3357941f","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both records carry distinct Singapore UEN registry identifiers (53406268K vs. 202549086N), which is conclusive proof of different legal entities. Proposer and skeptic agree unanimously. No merger is possible.","evidence_hash":"1f7f384d9137a0d6a08b29a7c99cf47565daea851bb9a269de65b16ce1ef5fba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:12.17259+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"061bd3b7-7f5c-48a9-8d64-00dc74ab19bb","company_lo":"3e751919-4fff-42be-97c9-e95802707f8b","company_hi":"a9c7f037-ba5c-4622-aa12-e82e3357941f","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: UEN:53406268K for GI AGENCY and UEN:202549086N for GRID AGENCY PTE. LTD. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low, and while the names share some superficial similarity, conflicting UENs override all other signals. No case for merging can be made.","evidence_hash":"1f7f384d9137a0d6a08b29a7c99cf47565daea851bb9a269de65b16ce1ef5fba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:12.17259+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2f2ca40a-829b-46e6-8255-916c1af8e46a","company_lo":"3e751919-4fff-42be-97c9-e95802707f8b","company_hi":"a9c7f037-ba5c-4622-aa12-e82e3357941f","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (53406268K vs. 202549086N) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The UEN formats also suggest different entity types and registration years, further supporting the distinction. All other signals are irrelevant.","evidence_hash":"1f7f384d9137a0d6a08b29a7c99cf47565daea851bb9a269de65b16ce1ef5fba","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:12.17259+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a25d83a7-16f7-40f9-a68b-052cf1d425d2","company_lo":"403272e2-49d4-45dd-9fa5-abaa281b37d6","company_hi":"5b58fd2c-3fae-4bcb-a1f9-10539318fb27","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (53392985K vs 200401404K) are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Names also differ substantively. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"279c7a43adc451ec4805fcd03e449311545b94dbabc771c8417203c88ce34568","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:06.155082+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5ff0d6fd-0757-4b8f-ae04-0588a3278b86","company_lo":"403272e2-49d4-45dd-9fa5-abaa281b37d6","company_hi":"5b58fd2c-3fae-4bcb-a1f9-10539318fb27","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (53392985K vs 200401404K), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ substantively: 'T & K ENGINEERING' vs 'T. M. ENGINEERING PTE. LTD.' — different middle initials and different legal structure. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no shared domain, no shared aliases, and no overlapping identifiers. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"279c7a43adc451ec4805fcd03e449311545b94dbabc771c8417203c88ce34568","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:06.155082+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"d28095f6-2f39-4fa6-b06b-1eb92d6f8973","company_lo":"403272e2-49d4-45dd-9fa5-abaa281b37d6","company_hi":"5b58fd2c-3fae-4bcb-a1f9-10539318fb27","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (53392985K vs 200401404K) conclusively prove these are distinct legal entities. All other evidence is irrelevant.","evidence_hash":"279c7a43adc451ec4805fcd03e449311545b94dbabc771c8417203c88ce34568","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:06.155082+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"67b6d3f0-9214-40e4-9884-880aafd5664a","company_lo":"48201ed2-3a4b-40f3-935e-29c18f493185","company_hi":"4b861be1-d6aa-4e59-9094-85406c4f7cd2","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.900,"rationale":"The only evidence is a case-normalized name match on 'ola' with a low detector score of 0.350. 'Ola' is an extremely common name used by many unrelated companies worldwide. There are no corroborating signals—no shared domain, no registry identifiers, no country, no aliases. A single common-word name match is insufficient to merge or definitively keep apart. Abstaining pending additional identifying information.","evidence_hash":"8ff8ac26f4621ab30b9bb8dba06807ae4574df7a5e3df977960dddca4e39f21e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:42.756708+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"caa4558c-e07f-4691-9618-75db1c237475","company_lo":"48201ed2-3a4b-40f3-935e-29c18f493185","company_hi":"4b861be1-d6aa-4e59-9094-85406c4f7cd2","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.500,"rationale":"The only signal here is a case-normalized name match on 'ola', which the detector flags at a low score of 0.350. 'Ola' is an extremely common word and company name used globally (e.g., Ola Cabs in India, Ola Electric, various unrelated businesses). There are no shared domains, registry identifiers, aliases, country data, or any other corroborating evidence to build a case for merging. While the normalized names are identical, a single common-word name match is the weakest possible evidence. I cannot argue persuasively for a merge with no supporting signals, nor can I definitively prove they are different entities. Abstaining pending additional identifying information.","evidence_hash":"8ff8ac26f4621ab30b9bb8dba06807ae4574df7a5e3df977960dddca4e39f21e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:42.756708+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0138f657-a7db-44c9-abd5-dfbf3d79f436","company_lo":"48201ed2-3a4b-40f3-935e-29c18f493185","company_hi":"4b861be1-d6aa-4e59-9094-85406c4f7cd2","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"8ff8ac26f4621ab30b9bb8dba06807ae4574df7a5e3df977960dddca4e39f21e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:46:42.756708+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"844e3134-94ca-487d-8412-2d1eebbae183","company_lo":"49694909-bc0b-441e-8896-661f386e5cc7","company_hi":"7a9a2ec7-5574-4229-a411-08f173066a6d","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the records carry distinct UENs (52925314C vs 200301889C), which is conclusive proof of separate legal entities. The low fuzzy score (0.330) and distinct names ('JUMP INTERNATIONAL MARKETING' vs 'JE INTERNATIONAL MARKETING PRIVATE LIMITED') further corroborate this conclusion. No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"c89da7dcae8fabf5c48f3ffcbcf901769618e44ea0df8b8f53414261e3f4eb7c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:15.471144+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0329b4c3-7398-4593-ae1b-d7d415d10baa","company_lo":"49694909-bc0b-441e-8896-661f386e5cc7","company_hi":"7a9a2ec7-5574-4229-a411-08f173066a6d","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have different UEN identifiers (52925314C vs 200301889C), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names are distinct — 'JUMP INTERNATIONAL MARKETING' vs 'JE INTERNATIONAL MARKETING PRIVATE LIMITED' — and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low, reflecting minimal similarity. There is no shared domain, alias, or any other evidence for merging.","evidence_hash":"c89da7dcae8fabf5c48f3ffcbcf901769618e44ea0df8b8f53414261e3f4eb7c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:15.471144+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"6246fc8e-9d92-4555-a523-373231e5eaa8","company_lo":"49694909-bc0b-441e-8896-661f386e5cc7","company_hi":"7a9a2ec7-5574-4229-a411-08f173066a6d","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The records have completely different UENs (52925314C vs 200301889C). Conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities, regardless of name similarity or fuzzy score. The names, while both containing 'INTERNATIONAL MARKETING', are clearly different ('JUMP' vs 'JE ... PRIVATE LIMITED'), further supporting that they are separate.","evidence_hash":"c89da7dcae8fabf5c48f3ffcbcf901769618e44ea0df8b8f53414261e3f4eb7c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:15.471144+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b9fe0bd3-b53f-44a6-a647-28898068c0d8","company_lo":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: Entity A (UEN:201017827N) and Entity B (UEN:201510242C) have distinct Singapore UENs, which is conclusive proof they are separate legal entities. The fuzzy name similarity between 'GH Solutions' and 'BH Solutions' is irrelevant given conflicting registry identifiers. No merging case can overcome differing government-issued identifiers.","evidence_hash":"9b9c77463f4990749257b6bc174bd10401f9c585a47bb5afc03381d565e74767","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:03.108368+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2596b561-d9fe-4e05-9006-a1cf8b590b70","company_lo":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 201017827N while Entity B has UEN 201510242C. These are distinct Singapore-registered companies. The name similarity (GH vs BH Solutions) is superficial and explained by the fuzzy matcher's low score of 0.330. Different UENs are definitive proof of separate legal entities; no merging case can overcome this.","evidence_hash":"9b9c77463f4990749257b6bc174bd10401f9c585a47bb5afc03381d565e74767","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:03.108368+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"57fb4220-9a5e-4506-9e1d-0a52e8531b0f","company_lo":"51f28627-533a-491a-9371-bcca8d2a7baf","company_hi":"6b11c92a-99b7-4cd7-9249-725ed507ab4c","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers: Entity A has UEN 201017827N while Entity B has UEN 201510242C. Different government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of separate legal entities, regardless of name similarity or detector score.","evidence_hash":"9b9c77463f4990749257b6bc174bd10401f9c585a47bb5afc03381d565e74767","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:03.108368+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c5fb1a31-1570-4236-ac5a-23a56d3e7335","company_lo":"5229ad1e-b20d-4699-8a9e-cb01c061c83a","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic correctly identify the conclusive evidence: conflicting UEN identifiers (53384759A vs 53006215A) prove these are distinct legal entities. The low fuzzy score (0.330), generic overlapping phrase 'Transport Services', and absence of shared domains or aliases provide no basis for merger. Conflicting registry identifiers are determinative.","evidence_hash":"866825664ee6eb257d6d8debab0cada0a178c4c7049262fdfffe365f11756236","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:11.090784+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e2949285-a49e-469d-9694-0aa5bcf7ec47","company_lo":"5229ad1e-b20d-4699-8a9e-cb01c061c83a","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: UEN:53384759A for RUDRAS TRANSPORT SERVICES and UEN:53006215A for RS TRANSPORT SERVICES. These are distinct government-issued registry identifiers, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low, and while both names contain 'Transport Services', this is a generic phrase offering no meaningful merger signal. No shared domains, aliases, or other corroborating evidence exists. The conflicting UENs are determinative — these are separate entities.","evidence_hash":"866825664ee6eb257d6d8debab0cada0a178c4c7049262fdfffe365f11756236","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:11.090784+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"84ede420-1cfa-4a7b-8be5-a220681f98d1","company_lo":"5229ad1e-b20d-4699-8a9e-cb01c061c83a","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The UENs are distinct government-issued identifiers: 53384759A vs 53006215A. Conflicting registry IDs are conclusive evidence of different legal entities, regardless of any superficial name similarity. The names share only the generic phrase 'Transport Services', and no shared domains or aliases exist to suggest a link. The detector's low confidence score further supports separation.","evidence_hash":"866825664ee6eb257d6d8debab0cada0a178c4c7049262fdfffe365f11756236","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:11.090784+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"ae239b3a-bc3f-47e2-a1b5-f37e6c5b423e","company_lo":"571ed57c-664a-450e-aa67-b41b3f84fefd","company_hi":"9d27cccb-caee-44f6-b78f-143b3343adf6","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (199206248R vs 52875320K) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The low fuzzy score (0.330) and weak name similarity provide no basis to override this.","evidence_hash":"74809255c679241f46a5ea6ee537ef9eed16e3b429d7191ffcc160532232dd5a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:17.324686+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"127e8cf1-9f53-4e42-ae96-699d7e749968","company_lo":"571ed57c-664a-450e-aa67-b41b3f84fefd","company_hi":"9d27cccb-caee-44f6-b78f-143b3343adf6","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:199206248R for DESIGN ACT PTE LTD and UEN:52875320K for ACT 2 DESIGN. Conflicting government-issued UENs are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Additionally, the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low, and while both names share the words 'ACT' and 'DESIGN', this name similarity is weak evidence that cannot override the conflicting identifiers.","evidence_hash":"74809255c679241f46a5ea6ee537ef9eed16e3b429d7191ffcc160532232dd5a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:17.324686+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0feb4afe-c7d7-40f6-92c7-b2237c8e8ccd","company_lo":"571ed57c-664a-450e-aa67-b41b3f84fefd","company_hi":"9d27cccb-caee-44f6-b78f-143b3343adf6","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two records have different government-issued UENs (199206248R vs 52875320K), which is conclusive proof they are separate legal entities. Name similarity, such as shared words 'ACT' and 'DESIGN', cannot override conflicting registry identifiers.","evidence_hash":"74809255c679241f46a5ea6ee537ef9eed16e3b429d7191ffcc160532232dd5a","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:17.324686+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"9046527b-6875-480b-9f93-3db9efdbfe6f","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: the UENs are conclusively different (52857139K vs 201103194H), the names differ (LAY vs JOY), and the detector score is very low. Conflicting registry identifiers alone mandate keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"c48abdc0c3a6df77bab5d0648d9482b815be7f658288979fc81f6c066f6bdccd","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:44.947568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"669d79e6-fbc2-4bec-aaeb-599868297cee","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:52857139K for Entity A and UEN:201103194H for Entity B. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ substantially ('LAY' vs 'JOY'), and the detector confidence is very low at 0.330. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"c48abdc0c3a6df77bab5d0648d9482b815be7f658288979fc81f6c066f6bdccd","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:44.947568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"f5bf26bb-fd91-4c9b-b047-d6be4e89940f","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The records have completely different UENs (52857139K vs 201103194H). Conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities, regardless of any other similarities. Additionally, the names differ (LAY vs JOY), and the detector confidence is low.","evidence_hash":"c48abdc0c3a6df77bab5d0648d9482b815be7f658288979fc81f6c066f6bdccd","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:44.947568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"ca667820-e2d7-4f42-ac37-f74114c9f18c","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: the UENs are conclusively different (52857139K vs 201425561R), establishing these as distinct legal entities. Name overlap is limited to generic industry terms. No basis for merger exists.","evidence_hash":"0e4cbed2f6f3e42e2657703470567fe75a44530706a733ab7edb7c3e308daba7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:58.653516+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"226b5ec3-227e-48a8-891e-fa89f9348f26","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records carry conflicting UEN identifiers (52857139K vs 201425561R), which is conclusive proof they are distinct legal entities. Beyond that, the names differ substantially: 'LAY ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION' versus 'MRL ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION PTE. LTD.' — only the generic words 'Engineering & Construction' overlap. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low and consistent with a superficial keyword match rather than genuine identity. There is no shared domain, no shared alias, and no overlapping registry data. No merger case can be made.","evidence_hash":"0e4cbed2f6f3e42e2657703470567fe75a44530706a733ab7edb7c3e308daba7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:58.653516+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"1f9b3b88-b0c5-42ff-a673-0ba25dd87840","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two records have different UENs (52857139K vs 201425561R). Conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities, overriding any name similarity or other evidence. The names share only the generic phrase 'ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION', with different prefixes (LAY vs MRL PTE. LTD.), further supporting separation.","evidence_hash":"0e4cbed2f6f3e42e2657703470567fe75a44530706a733ab7edb7c3e308daba7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:58.653516+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5286bb5a-c702-4346-b061-4d36a1a1a109","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the UEN identifiers are different (52857139K vs 202619736C), which is conclusive proof these are distinct legal entities. The low fuzzy score of 0.330 and common industry phrase 'Engineering & Construction' provide no meaningful evidence to the contrary.","evidence_hash":"e337c46539ee56e72a5c88c927cd715aa3b9c1c0caf5d9729e312f75d5dadfd5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:47.183117+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c48cbdeb-1de6-4c71-b7cc-11faa03f6b5a","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: UEN:52857139K for Entity A and UEN:202619736C for Entity B. Conflicting government-issued registry identifiers are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. No merger is possible regardless of any name similarity. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is also low, and while both names contain 'Engineering & Construction', that is a common phrase insufficient to overcome the definitive identifier conflict.","evidence_hash":"e337c46539ee56e72a5c88c927cd715aa3b9c1c0caf5d9729e312f75d5dadfd5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:47.183117+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cc5032ee-dc54-4ef8-8df2-923cfcc80475","company_lo":"5962083f-c886-43f5-bccb-68a63fc339cc","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued unique entity numbers (UEN:52857139K vs UEN:202619736C) conclusively establish these are distinct legal entities. No amount of name similarity or fuzzy score can override this definitive identifier mismatch.","evidence_hash":"e337c46539ee56e72a5c88c927cd715aa3b9c1c0caf5d9729e312f75d5dadfd5","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:47.183117+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"d42f2eda-8b82-4fe9-a9df-a3dd077d5700","company_lo":"5a12fc1d-332e-4fb7-bf8c-c697e66feb3b","company_hi":"6f1ee7b3-d8f8-4fb2-982a-0cb6d67d17e6","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both parties agree: conflicting UENs (36684600X vs 38849300C) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names also differ substantially in their distinctive elements. No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"462d394c2af4844867a258f772cbce3ed97f905bd6503fed1e85465f59167608","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:45.417801+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a28c7237-fcf4-471e-a4a5-5391c02b83f7","company_lo":"5a12fc1d-332e-4fb7-bf8c-c697e66feb3b","company_hi":"6f1ee7b3-d8f8-4fb2-982a-0cb6d67d17e6","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:36684600X for DARLINK MARKETING SERVICES and UEN:38849300C for APTRIN MARKETING SERVICES. These are distinct government-issued UENs, which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the entity names differ substantially — 'DARLINK' vs 'APTRIN' — with only the generic suffix 'MARKETING SERVICES' in common, which is weak evidence at best. The detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports separation. There is no basis for merging these records.","evidence_hash":"462d394c2af4844867a258f772cbce3ed97f905bd6503fed1e85465f59167608","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:45.417801+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"140e2565-62b9-4cf4-9803-d7914d16d1f1","company_lo":"5a12fc1d-332e-4fb7-bf8c-c697e66feb3b","company_hi":"6f1ee7b3-d8f8-4fb2-982a-0cb6d67d17e6","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued UENs (36684600X vs 38849300C) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names differ in the key distinctive elements ('DARLINK' vs 'APTRIN'), and the shared suffix 'MARKETING SERVICES' is generic. Detector score is low. No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"462d394c2af4844867a258f772cbce3ed97f905bd6503fed1e85465f59167608","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:45.417801+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2f971306-84fe-4a31-a70f-6c29c7f76d7c","company_lo":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (201103194H vs 202619736C) are conclusive proof of separate legal entities. The names also differ ('JOY' vs 'YE') and the detector score is low at 0.330. No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"8d100ac9f12875f8dd949c29a120abcb3e7aff0a72e65936eecc8b33aee33262","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:35.051692+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"26b9aba8-fbde-46e4-9e13-b27fa82fc47d","company_lo":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 201103194H and Entity B has UEN 202619736C. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving these are two separate legal entities. Additionally, the names differ ('JOY' vs 'YE'), and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is low. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"8d100ac9f12875f8dd949c29a120abcb3e7aff0a72e65936eecc8b33aee33262","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:35.051692+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"f535f00e-5860-4bbe-a31a-2bdf975b845d","company_lo":"619677f2-8999-40b8-8684-9f1e4cf999c5","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers: UEN 201103194H vs 202619736C. Different government-issued IDs are conclusive proof they are separate legal entities, regardless of partial name similarity or low detector score.","evidence_hash":"8d100ac9f12875f8dd949c29a120abcb3e7aff0a72e65936eecc8b33aee33262","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:35.051692+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"8b0c09a0-31aa-4f29-9e44-fca64a5d92d1","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (52895803L vs 53006215A) are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Names also differ ('ITS' vs 'RS' prefix), and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No basis for a merge.","evidence_hash":"407e30270b29778cf379676b3838534feb71fa4ec3f5d156fdf077d9106d074b","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:50.351369+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"5848b73c-7578-4137-8090-85603bd28967","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (52895803L vs 53006215A), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ ('ITS TRANSPORT SERVICES' vs 'RS TRANSPORT SERVICES'), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"407e30270b29778cf379676b3838534feb71fa4ec3f5d156fdf077d9106d074b","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:50.351369+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e34d432b-154c-474e-8807-6778ffbafdf4","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (52895803L vs 53006215A) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names share only generic terms 'TRANSPORT SERVICES' and have different prefixes ('ITS' vs 'RS'). No shared domains or other evidence exists to override the definitive registry identifier mismatch.","evidence_hash":"407e30270b29778cf379676b3838534feb71fa4ec3f5d156fdf077d9106d074b","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:50.351369+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"76c11b56-325e-415d-b444-c3e8ed094e8a","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (52895803L vs 52937302E) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names also differ materially (ITS vs LCS prefix), and the detector score is low at 0.330. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"db9b7091b7f49259ac580d9bac6817c8f9f9429e8b2f66320515acf2b05dcdb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:01.559286+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c40e79d4-17dd-4737-a43c-6415d6bccd97","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (52895803L vs 52937302E), which are government-issued registry IDs and constitute conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Additionally, the company names differ substantially — 'ITS TRANSPORT SERVICES' vs 'LCS TRANSPORT & SERVICES' — with different prefixes (ITS vs LCS). The detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports non-identity. There is no shared domain, no shared aliases, and no overlapping identifiers. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"db9b7091b7f49259ac580d9bac6817c8f9f9429e8b2f66320515acf2b05dcdb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:01.559286+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"30ac4fee-20cc-4b10-84f6-457281b80569","company_lo":"72b187b8-f923-4872-ae2c-a0a03fa5d1d9","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (52895803L vs 52937302E) are conclusive proof of different legal entities, overriding any name similarity. The names differ in their distinctive prefixes (ITS vs LCS) and the detector score is low (0.330). No shared identifiers, domain, or other linkage exists.","evidence_hash":"db9b7091b7f49259ac580d9bac6817c8f9f9429e8b2f66320515acf2b05dcdb7","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:01.559286+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"d732ce3b-847d-4587-bdaf-8dff5a1d6664","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic are in full agreement, and the evidence is unambiguous. The two records carry different government-issued UENs (52958482D vs. 200706789D), which per council rules constitutes conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL', the fuzzy score is very low (0.330), and there is no offsetting evidence for a merge. Ruling: keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"2a91711c9bf33d2daebaa8a871c05704c51822ae4d62ad7541987feaeb666f94","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:10.762989+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b48f35ab-dba0-469c-861a-f0e3d9a79449","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN 52958482D for SB INTERNATIONAL versus UEN 200706789D for LWS INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names share no meaningful overlap — 'SB' and 'LWS' are different prefixes, and the low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports they are distinct entities. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"2a91711c9bf33d2daebaa8a871c05704c51822ae4d62ad7541987feaeb666f94","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:10.762989+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"8ea8c655-8159-4421-b8d8-bad26de403ca","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The records have different, government-issued UENs (52958482D vs. 200706789D), which per council rules are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. No other evidence can override conflicting registry identifiers. Additionally, the names have only the common word 'INTERNATIONAL', and the fuzzy match score is very low (0.33).","evidence_hash":"2a91711c9bf33d2daebaa8a871c05704c51822ae4d62ad7541987feaeb666f94","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:10.762989+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e8c6a6fe-54f7-41bd-bdad-3010ab922e86","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct UEN identifiers (52958482D vs 201911072C), which constitutes conclusive proof of different legal entities. The name difference (SB vs SE), absence of shared domain or aliases, and very low fuzzy score (0.330) further reinforce this. No credible evidence supports merging.","evidence_hash":"a10547f436685e43fbad7de5ca27afbe3b12f0af325cd50a3466b1f26657934e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:12.532669+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b00a9e40-e423-454e-b10c-9f13dffda8da","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: UEN:52958482D for SB INTERNATIONAL versus UEN:201911072C for SE INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD. Per resolution rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names differ (SB vs SE prefix), the fuzzy match score is very low at 0.330, and there is no shared domain or alias overlap. There is no credible evidence for merging.","evidence_hash":"a10547f436685e43fbad7de5ca27afbe3b12f0af325cd50a3466b1f26657934e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:12.532669+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0f6e15b3-0547-470d-abf6-33e939379fe7","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers: UEN 52958482D vs UEN 201911072C. Government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof they are different entities, regardless of any name similarity or other evidence. The names differ in prefix (SB vs SE) and legal suffix, and the fuzzy score is low, but the identifier conflict alone is decisive.","evidence_hash":"a10547f436685e43fbad7de5ca27afbe3b12f0af325cd50a3466b1f26657934e","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:12.532669+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b7f0ad61-12ab-4964-906d-9890453cc6ad","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (52958482D vs 52837480W) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names differ ('SB INTERNATIONAL' vs 'PSH INTERNATIONAL'), fuzzy score is very low (0.330), and no shared domains or aliases exist. Both proposer and skeptic agree unanimously.","evidence_hash":"c70294d546d07fd39343f24f6733f46d16756721b23aedf77a17b0748cbdf212","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:23.569173+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"91f9ef5b-df6e-40b6-8a28-b964c0951130","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (52958482D vs 52837480W), which are conclusive proof they are different legal entities. The names are also different ('SB INTERNATIONAL' vs 'PSH INTERNATIONAL'), and the fuzzy match score of 0.330 is very low. There is no shared domain, alias, or any other evidence supporting a merge. These are definitively separate entities.","evidence_hash":"c70294d546d07fd39343f24f6733f46d16756721b23aedf77a17b0748cbdf212","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:23.569173+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"7cab2d27-23ba-4f09-b8cc-b4819e8b0030","company_lo":"76622cb3-9a4c-4f8a-8a25-2d92edea86ab","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have different, government-issued UEN identifiers (52958482D vs 52837480W), which is conclusive proof they are distinct legal entities. No weight should be given to name similarity or detector scores when registry identifiers conflict. The names themselves differ ('SB' vs 'PSH'), and the fuzzy match score of 0.330 is very low. There are no shared domains, aliases, or other evidence to suggest a connection.","evidence_hash":"c70294d546d07fd39343f24f6733f46d16756721b23aedf77a17b0748cbdf212","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:56:23.569173+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"be03826c-4521-4068-9f8b-a5129f7393bd","company_lo":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (53006215A vs 52937302E) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Both names and identifiers differ, and the low fuzzy score (0.330) provides no basis for merger.","evidence_hash":"e2c3d18c9c0b397e36408d398ae361bca9b45a6319bdbcaaf022d3409ac98864","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:01.272765+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e4e89731-8f1a-4f45-b55f-6bedf664f9b2","company_lo":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: 53006215A for RS TRANSPORT SERVICES and 52937302E for LCS TRANSPORT & SERVICES. Per resolution rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the company names differ substantially (RS vs LCS prefix, different full names), and the detector fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"e2c3d18c9c0b397e36408d398ae361bca9b45a6319bdbcaaf022d3409ac98864","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:01.272765+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4357541f-47fb-449e-a70f-c8fae83417ea","company_lo":"7bee4b83-d299-438c-b334-540755b95ae4","company_hi":"e9dbd644-b5ee-4cbc-ad02-9b9840e220cb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued UEN identifiers (53006215A vs 52937302E) are conclusive proof of separate legal entities. The names differ ('RS TRANSPORT SERVICES' vs 'LCS TRANSPORT & SERVICES'), and the fuzzy detector score is very low (0.330). No shared domains or other evidence suggests a match.","evidence_hash":"e2c3d18c9c0b397e36408d398ae361bca9b45a6319bdbcaaf022d3409ac98864","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:01.272765+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"909322a4-ffc7-4671-af99-f8aa12f72f8b","company_lo":"83f5b588-98c0-4a4f-a69e-8086162ff5ac","company_hi":"ba9b9c2e-1fdd-4ec8-8381-ea255998bc56","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct UEN identifiers (53009625X vs 202520191D), which under council rules constitute conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names are also clearly distinct, the fuzzy score is very low (0.330), and no shared domain or alias evidence exists. No basis for merger.","evidence_hash":"e161930dd80c9b6e336633f6e9bedddf93314afcd92b6959d523c93c6430826d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:09.569394+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b6a01143-55f5-4411-8150-ef27093cb9a2","company_lo":"83f5b588-98c0-4a4f-a69e-8086162ff5ac","company_hi":"ba9b9c2e-1fdd-4ec8-8381-ea255998bc56","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: UEN:53009625X for LIM INTERNATIONAL TRADING and UEN:202520191D for LINGXI INTERNATIONAL TRADING PTE. LTD. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the entity names are distinct (LIM vs LINGXI), the fuzzy detector score is very low at 0.330, and there is no shared domain or alias overlap. No basis for merger exists.","evidence_hash":"e161930dd80c9b6e336633f6e9bedddf93314afcd92b6959d523c93c6430826d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:09.569394+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"1ba657a3-7b50-4f45-87ec-faeda9e60229","company_lo":"83f5b588-98c0-4a4f-a69e-8086162ff5ac","company_hi":"ba9b9c2e-1fdd-4ec8-8381-ea255998bc56","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued registry identifiers (UEN:53009625X vs UEN:202520191D) provide conclusive proof they are different legal entities, overriding any name similarity. The names are distinct (LIM vs LINGXI) and generic components like 'INTERNATIONAL TRADING' are insufficient to link them. No shared domains or aliases exist.","evidence_hash":"e161930dd80c9b6e336633f6e9bedddf93314afcd92b6959d523c93c6430826d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:01:09.569394+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"870c3410-eed7-4892-8d12-fe2d6823e42c","company_lo":"8863bb18-21f8-439d-96b9-d425e4898b9a","company_hi":"e5e768fe-8c8c-4385-8cee-cfce6d54ec27","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records have conflicting UENs (39800800X vs 27940300C), which is conclusive proof of different legal entities. The names are also distinct, and the fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"ff0cae88adc66c99050d5e25fc18f86d1cfff314ec45aa571e818c8b4fce9c9c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:38.585751+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"d969a1bc-2d8d-40cb-8cb9-0565f91ad6ee","company_lo":"8863bb18-21f8-439d-96b9-d425e4898b9a","company_hi":"e5e768fe-8c8c-4385-8cee-cfce6d54ec27","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:39800800X for FOO LEONG TRADING and UEN:27940300C for CHOO LEONG TRADING CO. Conflicting government-issued UENs are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. The names are also distinct ('FOO' vs 'CHOO', with 'CO' suffix on one), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"ff0cae88adc66c99050d5e25fc18f86d1cfff314ec45aa571e818c8b4fce9c9c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:38.585751+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"9fc2341c-e6a6-43b6-abe4-e4b2d34db2a0","company_lo":"8863bb18-21f8-439d-96b9-d425e4898b9a","company_hi":"e5e768fe-8c8c-4385-8cee-cfce6d54ec27","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two records have completely different government-issued UENs (39800800X vs 27940300C). Conflicting UENs are conclusive proof of different legal entities, overriding any name similarity. Additionally, the names are distinct ('FOO' vs 'CHOO', and one includes 'CO'), and the detector score is low (0.330). There is no evidence for merging.","evidence_hash":"ff0cae88adc66c99050d5e25fc18f86d1cfff314ec45aa571e818c8b4fce9c9c","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:38.585751+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"15dab65e-d9bb-449d-a774-685ee39b6a10","company_lo":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","company_hi":"d2d8a9d6-ad73-4038-a93d-b1684f23cc9e","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the conflicting UEN identifiers (53115419W vs 202404962W) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities under council rules. Additionally, the names differ in prefix, pluralization, and legal structure, and the detector score is low at 0.330. No evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"57c4254f294cbd40e57126445d65ca081f7be1549b510f00d3049ec423bca0f0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:25.757756+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"3d9c3e13-782a-4693-ac11-e562686ff5f6","company_lo":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","company_hi":"d2d8a9d6-ad73-4038-a93d-b1684f23cc9e","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN registry identifiers: UEN:53115419W for SP GENERAL CONTRACTOR and UEN:202404962W for KSP GENERAL CONTRACTORS PTE. LTD. Per the council's rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities, regardless of any name similarity. The names also differ materially — one includes the prefix 'K' and the designation 'PTE. LTD.' — and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"57c4254f294cbd40e57126445d65ca081f7be1549b510f00d3049ec423bca0f0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:25.757756+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c5ca2b62-c7bb-4cd8-b21b-513944f19a63","company_lo":"8cf6b3eb-566b-477e-bd10-703164c4dc2a","company_hi":"d2d8a9d6-ad73-4038-a93d-b1684f23cc9e","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (53115419W vs 202404962W) are conclusive proof of separate legal entities under council rules. The names differ in prefix ('SP' vs 'KSP'), pluralization ('CONTRACTOR' vs 'CONTRACTORS'), and legal suffix (none vs 'PTE. LTD.'). No shared domains, no shared identifiers, and a low detector score of 0.330. These are clearly distinct companies.","evidence_hash":"57c4254f294cbd40e57126445d65ca081f7be1549b510f00d3049ec423bca0f0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:25.757756+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cd0e45fa-00a0-4cc7-999e-75fbff00ed95","company_lo":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: the two records carry distinct, conflicting UEN identifiers (200706789D vs 201911072C), which is conclusive proof of separate legal entities under resolution rules. The company names also differ materially ('LWS' vs 'SE'), and the fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is well below any merge threshold. No evidence supports merging.","evidence_hash":"3bae8a3c43436ea325841225e4f81f74422bdc72c0a1f38cd4cf52c1342537c3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:23.09846+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"40c2e3b9-6e8f-4b2d-844b-eaec06cd6dce","company_lo":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers: UEN:200706789D for LWS INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD. and UEN:201911072C for SE INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD. Per resolution rules, conflicting government-issued registry identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Furthermore, the company names differ substantially ('LWS' vs 'SE'), and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"3bae8a3c43436ea325841225e4f81f74422bdc72c0a1f38cd4cf52c1342537c3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:23.09846+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a5cf173a-b446-4fdb-90fa-f9889ac0fcbd","company_lo":"9554128b-8db3-415d-b639-b2c6d728d5fc","company_hi":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The two records have different, unique UEN identifiers (200706789D vs 201911072C). Conflicting government-issued registry identifiers conclusively prove they are distinct legal entities, regardless of any surface similarities. The company names also differ significantly ('LWS' vs 'SE'). There is no evidence for merging.","evidence_hash":"3bae8a3c43436ea325841225e4f81f74422bdc72c0a1f38cd4cf52c1342537c3","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:23.09846+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e31a49fb-1853-4246-a736-e1cec5b98be1","company_lo":"a8252615-b1d4-4481-b575-f2bbc42edead","company_hi":"b6fd397a-ad69-4c3c-b4c5-7420f760034b","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (201725857D vs 200501718N) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Both proposer and skeptic agree. The differing name prefixes (SCE vs RDC) and low fuzzy score of 0.330 further support separation.","evidence_hash":"41bc05ca49491dad0a4b154398d203bd8a9e62641328c2564521314695feaaa1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:05.789874+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"870a593b-f689-4a03-8e2b-15061679f919","company_lo":"a8252615-b1d4-4481-b575-f2bbc42edead","company_hi":"b6fd397a-ad69-4c3c-b4c5-7420f760034b","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 201725857D while Entity B has UEN 200501718N. These are distinct government-issued registration numbers, proving these are two separate legal entities. Additionally, the company names differ in their prefix (SCE vs RDC), and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is low. No evidence supports merging.","evidence_hash":"41bc05ca49491dad0a4b154398d203bd8a9e62641328c2564521314695feaaa1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:05.789874+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"73dbfb09-6891-46ca-8756-2c31cd5b74ab","company_lo":"a8252615-b1d4-4481-b575-f2bbc42edead","company_hi":"b6fd397a-ad69-4c3c-b4c5-7420f760034b","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers provide conclusive proof these are distinct legal entities. UEN 201725857D differs from 200501718N, which cannot occur for the same company. Additionally, company names differ by prefix (SCE vs RDC), and the low detector score of 0.330 is consistent with separate entities.","evidence_hash":"41bc05ca49491dad0a4b154398d203bd8a9e62641328c2564521314695feaaa1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:05.789874+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"1bd5d03b-5a78-4dfb-972e-b8b47286373d","company_lo":"ab30fe1f-b84a-43d2-9b50-2c98cb05aa6c","company_hi":"f9f55c33-bec7-457c-9439-84e444427c2a","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (202127231C vs 200706703R) are conclusive proof these are distinct legal entities. The loose name similarity ('Genesis' in both) and low fuzzy score of 0.330 provide no countervailing evidence. These are different companies.","evidence_hash":"f87ae43fe7bd9fcfa313212b2d7fa4ce1e00bef4fc20bbb4d34c0eec794c27df","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:45.594504+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"c14985f8-4657-4635-a453-bce3645ffe2d","company_lo":"ab30fe1f-b84a-43d2-9b50-2c98cb05aa6c","company_hi":"f9f55c33-bec7-457c-9439-84e444427c2a","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 202127231C while Entity B has UEN 200706703R. These are distinct government-issued registration numbers, proving these are two different legal entities. There is no mergeable evidence that can override this — not the loose name similarity ('Genesis' appears in both but with different numerics: '933' vs '3'), not the low fuzzy score of 0.330, and not any shared domain or alias. The records must be kept apart.","evidence_hash":"f87ae43fe7bd9fcfa313212b2d7fa4ce1e00bef4fc20bbb4d34c0eec794c27df","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:45.594504+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"75d28970-47f6-4178-a44a-29d8cc136500","company_lo":"ab30fe1f-b84a-43d2-9b50-2c98cb05aa6c","company_hi":"f9f55c33-bec7-457c-9439-84e444427c2a","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The entities have different government-issued UENs: 202127231C vs 200706703R. Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities, overriding any superficial name similarity or low detector confidence.","evidence_hash":"f87ae43fe7bd9fcfa313212b2d7fa4ce1e00bef4fc20bbb4d34c0eec794c27df","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:59:45.594504+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"e9c6842b-2588-46c2-8ea0-da270de84ad1","company_lo":"ab7ba00c-07cf-4f14-9981-1e79f02c73b2","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (52832603A vs 202619736C) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Name similarity in generic industry terms ('Engineering & Construction') is weak, detector score is low (0.33), and no unifying signals exist.","evidence_hash":"b314bc5330b98641b3d277c9cf4bf28822050dd20bc9b27d945cb5d153a15432","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:47.746674+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b197875a-c336-42a9-a56f-d80cb9d5f12d","company_lo":"ab7ba00c-07cf-4f14-9981-1e79f02c73b2","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:52832603A for Entity A and UEN:202619736C for Entity B. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low, and while both names contain 'Engineering & Construction', this overlap is common in the industry and constitutes weak evidence at best. There is no shared domain, no shared aliases, and no other same-entity signals that could overcome the conflicting UENs.","evidence_hash":"b314bc5330b98641b3d277c9cf4bf28822050dd20bc9b27d945cb5d153a15432","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:47.746674+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cccc6978-beb5-44b1-9475-a8297687ee72","company_lo":"ab7ba00c-07cf-4f14-9981-1e79f02c73b2","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have completely different UENs (52832603A vs 202619736C). Per council rules, conflicting government-issued registry identifiers are conclusive proof they are different legal entities, regardless of any superficial name similarities. The name overlap ('ENGINEERING' and 'CONSTRUCTION') is generic and weak evidence. No shared domain, aliases, or other unifying signals exist. The detector's low confidence (0.33) further supports separate entities.","evidence_hash":"b314bc5330b98641b3d277c9cf4bf28822050dd20bc9b27d945cb5d153a15432","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:58:47.746674+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"94c1b9ac-4182-4bfb-82c2-d462db282d4f","company_lo":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (201425561R vs 202619736C) are conclusive proof these are different legal entities. Name prefixes also differ (MRL vs YE). The low fuzzy score of 0.330 reflects only a common industry suffix. No basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"e6796e65328c44daedab084a49ba55f1b9ceaf73bef65d7fb9d22d1de2c80829","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:10.987568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"51656425-1558-4c56-9084-bd88fdaa3cb5","company_lo":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UENs (201425561R vs 202619736C), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Despite the superficial similarity in the 'ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION PTE. LTD.' suffix, the company prefixes differ (MRL vs YE) and the government-issued registry identifiers are distinct. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low and attributable solely to the common industry suffix. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"e6796e65328c44daedab084a49ba55f1b9ceaf73bef65d7fb9d22d1de2c80829","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:10.987568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"6593695d-b51c-4c52-b51e-45824cc5b42a","company_lo":"af98932e-662a-4b50-baca-4f1edbadcbaf","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"The records have different, conflicting Unique Entity Numbers (UEN:201425561R vs UEN:202619736C). According to the instructions, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different entities, regardless of any other similarities. The company name prefixes also differ ('MRL' vs 'YE'), but the identifiers alone are dispositive.","evidence_hash":"e6796e65328c44daedab084a49ba55f1b9ceaf73bef65d7fb9d22d1de2c80829","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T15:00:10.987568+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"0fed547c-002c-4e3a-8531-0b3a5bfc9c67","company_lo":"b10b3ae7-03ec-423f-8879-fb05ac969560","company_hi":"f28ae128-0f3b-481c-b29a-9ad2d888d7b3","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers (202001348G vs 52972229A) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL' and are otherwise completely different. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"a0ea4a79ef802f56a97b64d02d816dd493178a14a4fc0408e4b6ea5cecd58901","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:25.873994+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"8a54dadf-4596-45ce-9076-9055a4b87a7c","company_lo":"b10b3ae7-03ec-423f-8879-fb05ac969560","company_hi":"f28ae128-0f3b-481c-b29a-9ad2d888d7b3","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 202001348G while Entity B has UEN 52972229A. These are distinct government-issued identifiers proving they are separate legal entities. Additionally, the names 'KYLIN INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD.' and 'MAYLION INTERNATIONAL' share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL' and are otherwise entirely different. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is very low, consistent with no meaningful similarity. There is no basis for merging.","evidence_hash":"a0ea4a79ef802f56a97b64d02d816dd493178a14a4fc0408e4b6ea5cecd58901","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:25.873994+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"fccd1714-1036-427b-bbb2-0a889f7bf7dc","company_lo":"b10b3ae7-03ec-423f-8879-fb05ac969560","company_hi":"f28ae128-0f3b-481c-b29a-9ad2d888d7b3","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"a0ea4a79ef802f56a97b64d02d816dd493178a14a4fc0408e4b6ea5cecd58901","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:55:25.873994+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2dc370e8-3841-424b-9474-be0f98dc5676","company_lo":"b42f0385-fcd7-4bc6-abb1-0e56977ec2f9","company_hi":"e763cc11-f4da-48c5-9070-5249c5aa0497","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (53115570J vs 45608400B) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names differ, the detector score is low (0.330), and no shared domains or aliases exist. No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"b6be747a236ddc290fe05b3d160940011d83cda09bba8528c64a2427cdfec28d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:15.6183+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cc893115-ce16-4f5a-885b-8e55f49dbf17","company_lo":"b42f0385-fcd7-4bc6-abb1-0e56977ec2f9","company_hi":"e763cc11-f4da-48c5-9070-5249c5aa0497","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 53115570J and Entity B has UEN 45608400B. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving they are different legal entities. The names 'VICCO ENTERPRISE' and 'YICO ENTERPRISE' are also distinct despite superficial similarity, and the detector's fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low. No shared domains, aliases, or any other merging signals are present. There is no credible case for merging.","evidence_hash":"b6be747a236ddc290fe05b3d160940011d83cda09bba8528c64a2427cdfec28d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:15.6183+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4db28300-c52d-4314-8218-324f0073eb26","company_lo":"b42f0385-fcd7-4bc6-abb1-0e56977ec2f9","company_hi":"e763cc11-f4da-48c5-9070-5249c5aa0497","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued identifiers (UEN:53115570J vs UEN:45608400B) are conclusive proof of different legal entities, per instructions. No shared domain, aliases, or other merging signals override this. Name similarity is superficial and the detector score is low.","evidence_hash":"b6be747a236ddc290fe05b3d160940011d83cda09bba8528c64a2427cdfec28d","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:57:15.6183+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"f718e689-4f8c-4c82-b5d5-143f59b44d7c","company_lo":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both the proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (199301693E vs 202619736C) are conclusive proof these are distinct legal entities. The differing company names and low fuzzy score (0.330) further confirm this. No basis for a merge exists.","evidence_hash":"d3fcfd71c3aee037298560c7c92fe7bd0cc89ca9b3ed9f6589e40b3b5300e4a0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:01.182175+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a3ca0b61-b0fc-48fb-8721-cc3aaa311210","company_lo":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting UEN identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN:199301693E and Entity B has UEN:202619736C. These are distinct government-issued registration numbers, proving these are two different legal entities. The company names are also different (D N ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION vs YE ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION), and the fuzzy match score of 0.330 is low. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"d3fcfd71c3aee037298560c7c92fe7bd0cc89ca9b3ed9f6589e40b3b5300e4a0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:01.182175+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"61c04217-b5b0-4af1-8463-8c5dbc9ba5af","company_lo":"b603da35-dc36-4068-8b6c-e9799686d393","company_hi":"ce1d0e89-5a21-4462-b583-735cf5589cdb","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (199301693E vs 202619736C) are conclusive proof of different legal entities. The name differences (D N vs YE) and low detector score (0.330) further support this conclusion.","evidence_hash":"d3fcfd71c3aee037298560c7c92fe7bd0cc89ca9b3ed9f6589e40b3b5300e4a0","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:01.182175+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"dff46ba6-0481-4c89-bf0d-465e827d22ea","company_lo":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UEN identifiers (201911072C vs 52837480W) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL', detector score is low (0.330), and no shared domains or aliases exist. These are unambiguously different entities.","evidence_hash":"7aac3f5dafdfb91e34a46fc78601ad7851360d933f8dd1a3bb1f2b398374a7ff","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:34.381748+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"defe68c0-dae4-4a6c-ae60-11382f97e786","company_lo":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting UEN identifiers (201911072C vs 52837480W), which is conclusive proof they are different legal entities. Additionally, the names 'SE INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD.' and 'PSH INTERNATIONAL' share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL' and are otherwise distinct. The detector fuzzy score of 0.330 is very low, further supporting separation. No shared domains, aliases, or other overlapping signals exist. These are unambiguously different entities.","evidence_hash":"7aac3f5dafdfb91e34a46fc78601ad7851360d933f8dd1a3bb1f2b398374a7ff","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:34.381748+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"ad40ff42-2fcf-44bb-a78f-4f94bc3ad7c2","company_lo":"ca2edec3-6119-401a-89a5-a7e1c7889ede","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting unique entity numbers (UENs: 201911072C vs 52837480W) are conclusive that these are distinct legal entities. The names share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL' and differ in their identifying parts (SE vs PSH). The low fuzzy detector score (0.330) further supports separation. No shared domain or other linking evidence.","evidence_hash":"7aac3f5dafdfb91e34a46fc78601ad7851360d933f8dd1a3bb1f2b398374a7ff","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:53:34.381748+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"bb36152e-fd66-4ee2-8018-3f3bb976d186","company_lo":"d15a27c4-8c9e-4d8c-9c9f-1da09d7ccd0c","company_hi":"f70fc68d-5ddb-4a88-bb52-8ae3d73ab987","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting UENs (53374897J vs 53230800W) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Both proposer and skeptic agree, names differ, and the low fuzzy score of 0.330 corroborates separation.","evidence_hash":"1d361146f8e01454acb76da6f8d0bda539ad6291bc1179daa5ab6dd5836a1435","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:22.383727+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"cf039912-38c2-4d9b-afd8-839392dbbfe2","company_lo":"d15a27c4-8c9e-4d8c-9c9f-1da09d7ccd0c","company_hi":"f70fc68d-5ddb-4a88-bb52-8ae3d73ab987","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN 53374897J and Entity B has UEN 53230800W. These are distinct government-issued identifiers, proving these are two different legal entities. The names are also clearly different ('GM TRAINING CONSULTANCY' vs 'MFR-TRAINING & CONSULTANCY'), and the detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further supports separation. No basis for merging exists.","evidence_hash":"1d361146f8e01454acb76da6f8d0bda539ad6291bc1179daa5ab6dd5836a1435","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:22.383727+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"087394ce-73ca-407a-bae4-777bda0780a9","company_lo":"d15a27c4-8c9e-4d8c-9c9f-1da09d7ccd0c","company_hi":"f70fc68d-5ddb-4a88-bb52-8ae3d73ab987","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Different UENs (53374897J vs 53230800W) conclusively indicate separate legal entities. The names, while both containing 'TRAINING' and 'CONSULTANCY', have different prefixes and a low matching score. No shared identifiers or domains.","evidence_hash":"1d361146f8e01454acb76da6f8d0bda539ad6291bc1179daa5ab6dd5836a1435","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:57:22.383727+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"b2acf723-e25a-4501-8027-17d3fb7b55a0","company_lo":"d8ca0720-0515-458e-9a07-62c19fd72047","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: the records carry conflicting UENs (200922531C vs 52837480W), which is conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. The names share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL', the fuzzy score is a low 0.330, and there is no corroborating evidence for a merge. Ruling keep_apart.","evidence_hash":"0800622156dd8f147d1726bb40df15c18d8a4386ecaf7c94a895b91caa1d8356","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:38.727712+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4cd10eaf-ca8c-4dfb-8068-6c007d00418e","company_lo":"d8ca0720-0515-458e-9a07-62c19fd72047","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The two records have conflicting registry identifiers: UEN:200922531C for Entity A and UEN:52837480W for Entity B. Per council rules, conflicting government-issued identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities. Additionally, the names 'ISHA INTERNATIONAL PTE. LTD.' and 'PSH INTERNATIONAL' share only the generic word 'INTERNATIONAL' and are otherwise dissimilar. The detector's low fuzzy score of 0.330 further confirms weak name similarity. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"0800622156dd8f147d1726bb40df15c18d8a4386ecaf7c94a895b91caa1d8356","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:38.727712+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"6a862782-999c-4200-9225-c88162165c62","company_lo":"d8ca0720-0515-458e-9a07-62c19fd72047","company_hi":"f6f4a42e-3a99-4648-85a6-1a8136fd1f82","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"The records have different UENs: 200922531C vs 52837480W. Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive proof of different legal entities per council rules. The shared word 'INTERNATIONAL' is generic and the detector's low score of 0.330 reflects weak name similarity. No other evidence supports a merge.","evidence_hash":"0800622156dd8f147d1726bb40df15c18d8a4386ecaf7c94a895b91caa1d8356","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T14:54:38.727712+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"2cf3b730-1b64-45bb-964c-6a0726492fe2","company_lo":"d9f50b1f-e272-4532-9aea-0da49a2c331a","company_hi":"f3b213f6-ab2e-4d53-a8c0-cb7b05bf5607","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Both proposer and skeptic agree: conflicting UENs (35126700W vs 32720800K) are conclusive proof of distinct legal entities. Names also differ materially. No basis for merge.","evidence_hash":"54ed18f849e334e6488ee3bd4feab3ed0b0afaa74e4c7762d306f1121d8065c1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.09982+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"984e64f3-2813-4b21-a0de-d054050d85a0","company_lo":"d9f50b1f-e272-4532-9aea-0da49a2c331a","company_hi":"f3b213f6-ab2e-4d53-a8c0-cb7b05bf5607","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":0.990,"rationale":"Conflicting registry identifiers are conclusive: Entity A has UEN:35126700W and Entity B has UEN:32720800K. These are different government-issued identifiers, proving these are distinct legal entities. The names are also different ('SECON PANG' vs 'ONN KANG'), sharing only the generic descriptor 'ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING'. The fuzzy detector score of 0.330 is low and reflects only superficial word overlap. There is no evidence supporting a merge.","evidence_hash":"54ed18f849e334e6488ee3bd4feab3ed0b0afaa74e4c7762d306f1121d8065c1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.09982+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"013f86d0-aa66-400e-81cb-21de68f2db4f","company_lo":"d9f50b1f-e272-4532-9aea-0da49a2c331a","company_hi":"f3b213f6-ab2e-4d53-a8c0-cb7b05bf5607","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"keep_apart","confidence":1.000,"rationale":"Conflicting government-issued identifiers (UEN 35126700W vs UEN 32720800K) conclusively prove these are different legal entities. The names differ ('SECON PANG' vs 'ONN KANG') and share only the generic descriptive suffix 'ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING'. The low detector score (0.330) reflects weak surface similarity, insufficient to override the decisive identifier conflict.","evidence_hash":"54ed18f849e334e6488ee3bd4feab3ed0b0afaa74e4c7762d306f1121d8065c1","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-06-30T08:51:30.09982+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"a36d1a55-d317-4acc-babb-685395ae7cef","company_lo":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"judge","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.720,"rationale":"The name 'Byju' is highly distinctive and not a generic term. Entity A ('byju's') and Entity B ('Byjus') differ only by the presence/absence of an apostrophe, which is a well-known stylistic variation of the same globally recognized edtech brand. No conflicting registry identifiers, domains, or country fields are present to contradict a merge. The proposer's argument is sound, and the skeptic failed to produce a counter-argument. The low fuzzy score (0.330) reflects the apostrophe difference rather than semantic divergence. On balance, the uniqueness of the brand name and absence of any conflicting evidence support merging these records.","evidence_hash":"7f7c08fb5b7e95058f131396203dacdfbfb8b19077a9cf1c8e9945029b12e1eb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:25.316093+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"12ad4fd7-a506-44bb-995d-443cb339e1cd","company_lo":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"proposer","model_family":"anthropic","model_id":"claude-sonnet-4-6","verdict":"merge","confidence":0.620,"rationale":"Both records refer to 'Byju's' — a globally recognized edtech brand. Entity A uses the apostrophe form 'byju's' and Entity B uses the simplified 'Byjus', which is a common stylistic variation of the same brand name, especially in informal or system-constrained contexts where apostrophes are dropped. The name 'Byju' is highly distinctive and not a common word, making a coincidental name match extremely unlikely. There are no conflicting registry identifiers, domains, or country fields provided that would contradict a merge. The absence of conflicting identifiers combined with the uniqueness of the brand name supports treating these as the same legal entity.","evidence_hash":"7f7c08fb5b7e95058f131396203dacdfbfb8b19077a9cf1c8e9945029b12e1eb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:25.316093+00:00","failure_reason":null}, {"id":"4a661225-518b-4e1e-baa5-e8b0404d6026","company_lo":"db22e1d0-76c9-47e2-a3a1-5f6a3cdc2f7b","company_hi":"e65ccdc0-0e4c-465f-ba28-a618184c03db","member_role":"skeptic","model_family":"deepseek","model_id":"deepseek-v4-pro","verdict":"abstain","confidence":0.000,"rationale":"abstain: MemberOutputError","evidence_hash":"7f7c08fb5b7e95058f131396203dacdfbfb8b19077a9cf1c8e9945029b12e1eb","prompt_version":"c2","created_at":"2026-07-01T12:47:25.316093+00:00","failure_reason":null}]